---
verdict: pass
remediation_round: 0
---

# Milestone Validation: M017

## Success Criteria Checklist
- [x] **Hero section with avatar/bio/social links** — S01 delivered 96px avatar, bio, genre pills; S02 added social link icons with 9 platform SVGs + fallback. Build passes, schema sync verified.
- [x] **Stats dashboard** — S02 added technique/video/moment counts. Backend `moment_count` field added via KeyMoment→SourceVideo join. Stats bar with dot separators confirmed.
- [x] **Featured technique highlight** — S03 delivered featured card with gradient border-image, summary, tags, moment count. First technique extracted from sorted array.
- [x] **Improved technique grid** — S03 restyled remaining cards to `recent-card` pattern with enriched fields (summary, topic_tags, key_moment_count).
- [x] **Admin can edit profile fields** — S04 delivered inline edit mode for bio (textarea) and social links (platform dropdown + URL rows). Optimistic local state update after PUT.
- [x] **Mobile polish** — S04 added @media (max-width: 480px) block with 15 CSS overrides. UAT covers 375px viewport.

## Slice Delivery Audit
| Slice | Claimed Output | Delivered | Verdict |
|-------|---------------|-----------|---------|
| S01 | Hero with avatar, name, bio, genre pills. All backend fields consumed. | CreatorDetailResponse extended with 7 fields. Hero section with 96px avatar, 2rem name, conditional bio, genre pills. Redundant fetchTechniques eliminated. Build clean. | ✅ Delivered |
| S02 | Social link icons in hero. Stats bar with technique/video/moment counts. | SocialIcons.tsx with 9 platforms + fallback. moment_count added to backend+frontend. Stats bar with three counts and dot separators. Build clean. | ✅ Delivered |
| S03 | Featured technique card prominent. All cards use recent-card styling. | Featured card with gradient border, summary, tags, moment count. Grid cards restyled to recent-card with enriched data. Backend query enriched with summary, topic_tags, key_moment_count. Build clean. | ✅ Delivered |
| S04 | Admin edit bio/social links. Page looks good at 375px. | Inline edit mode with bio textarea, social links editor (add/remove rows), save/cancel, optimistic update. 480px breakpoint with 15 responsive overrides. Build clean. | ✅ Delivered |

## Cross-Slice Integration
No boundary mismatches found. All cross-slice dependencies satisfied:
- **S01→S02:** S02 consumed the hero section layout and CreatorDetailResponse schema from S01 to add social icons and stats.
- **S01→S03:** S03 consumed the technique list rendering from S01, enriched the data, and split into featured + grid.
- **S01+S02→S04:** S04 consumed the hero section (S01) and social links display (S02) to build the inline edit mode.

All `provides`/`requires` entries in slice summaries are consistent with actual deliverables.

## Requirement Coverage
No specific requirement IDs were mapped to this milestone in the roadmap. The milestone is a UI enhancement milestone (creator profile page polish) that advances the overall product quality but was not tied to tracked requirements.

## Verification Class Compliance
**Contract:** ✅ Met. All four slices report `tsc --noEmit` exit 0 and `npm run build` exit 0. Creator detail page renders all profile fields from the API (schema sync verified in S01, enrichment in S02/S03).

**Integration:** ✅ Met. S04 implements admin PUT that saves to DB and updates local state optimistically. UAT TC-03 tests persistence across page reload.

**Operational:** ⚠️ Partially met. No evidence of runtime operational verification against the live app — all verification was build-time (tsc, npm run build) and code-level (grep). UAT cases specify checking for console/network errors but UAT documents are written for manual execution, not executed in automation. This is consistent with project norms but means no runtime evidence exists.

**UAT:** ✅ Met. Comprehensive UAT test cases written for all four slices (41 test cases total) covering all claimed deliverables, edge cases, and responsive behavior.


## Verdict Rationale
All four slices delivered their claimed outputs as verified by build-time checks and code inspection. Success criteria fully met: hero section, stats dashboard, featured technique, grid restyle, admin editing, and mobile polish all implemented. Cross-slice integration is clean. The only gap is operational runtime verification (no console/network error checks against the live app), which is consistent with project norms where UAT docs are written for manual execution. Known limitations (border-image/border-radius, featured technique is first-in-sort-order only) are documented and minor. Pass.
