---
verdict: pass
remediation_round: 0
---

# Milestone Validation: M018

## Success Criteria Checklist
The roadmap has no explicit success criteria section, so validation uses the Vision statement and Verification Classes as the governing criteria.

- [x] **Site Audit Report produced** — SITE-AUDIT-REPORT.md exists at 467 lines with 9 H2 sections (Executive Summary, Route Map, Component Inventory, API Surface Map, Data Model, CSS Architecture, Infrastructure Stack, Phase 2 Integration Recommendations, Appendix). All sections substantive.
- [x] **Route map complete** — 12 routes documented, all verified live via browser navigation at ub01:8096.
- [x] **API surface mapped** — 41 endpoints documented across public, browse, report, and admin domains. 22 probed via curl with response shapes recorded.
- [x] **Component inventory** — Shared components, hooks, and utils documented in report.
- [x] **Phase 2 integration recommendations** — 8 risks with mitigations documented, cross-referencing 12 existing DECISIONS.md entries.
- [x] **Forgejo wiki bootstrapped** — 10 wiki pages confirmed via Forgejo API at git.xpltd.co/xpltdco/chrysopedia/wiki/ (Home + 9 content pages).
- [x] **Wiki covers core architecture** — Pages: Architecture, Data-Model, API-Surface, Frontend, Pipeline, Deployment, Development-Guide, Decisions, Home. Well exceeds the ≥6 page threshold.

## Slice Delivery Audit
| Slice | Claimed Deliverable | Delivered | Verified |
|-------|---------------------|-----------|----------|
| S01 | Site Audit Report with route map, component inventory, API surface map, and integration recommendations | SITE-AUDIT-REPORT.md (467 lines, 9 sections) + AUDIT-FINDINGS.md + S01-RESEARCH.md | ✅ File exists, line count confirmed, section count confirmed |
| S02 | Forgejo wiki at forgejo.xpltd.co with comprehensive Chrysopedia architecture documentation | 10 wiki pages at git.xpltd.co/xpltdco/chrysopedia/wiki/ | ✅ API confirms 10 pages present |

**S02 domain deviation:** Roadmap said "forgejo.xpltd.co" but actual canonical domain is "git.xpltd.co" per Forgejo app.ini ROOT_URL. S02 summary documents this deviation. The wiki is accessible — the domain name difference is cosmetic.

## Cross-Slice Integration
S01 provides the Site Audit Report that S02 uses as a primary source for wiki content. S02 summary confirms it synthesized from S01's report plus PROJECT.md, DECISIONS.md, KNOWLEDGE.md, and source code. The boundary is clean — S01 produced the reference material, S02 consumed it.

No mismatches detected. The slices are independent (S02 doesn't formally depend on S01 in the roadmap) but S02 was executed after S01, enabling it to incorporate audit findings.

## Requirement Coverage
M018 is an audit/documentation milestone — it does not directly advance or validate any active requirements (R015, R037, R038, R039, R041). Its purpose is to produce reference artifacts for Phase 2 planning. No requirements are expected to change status from this milestone.

## Verification Class Compliance
### Contract
**Status: PASS**
- Site Audit Report exists with all 6+ sections populated (actual: 9 H2 sections, 467 lines). ✅
- Forgejo wiki has ≥6 pages covering core architecture (actual: 10 pages — Home, Architecture, Data-Model, API-Surface, Frontend, Pipeline, Deployment, Development-Guide, Decisions, _Sidebar). ✅

### Integration
**Status: PASS**
- Audit report includes "Phase 2 Integration Recommendations" section with 8 risks and specific mitigations per planned feature. ✅
- Cross-references 12 existing DECISIONS.md entries for continuity. ✅

### Operational
**Status: PASS**
- Forgejo wiki verified accessible via API at git.xpltd.co (10 pages returned from `/api/v1/repos/xpltdco/chrysopedia/wiki/pages`). ✅
- Domain is git.xpltd.co (not forgejo.xpltd.co as planned) — minor cosmetic deviation, wiki is live and accessible.

### UAT
**Status: PASS (by design)**
- The UAT criterion ("newcomer can understand Chrysopedia without reading source code") is a qualitative judgment. Evidence: wiki pages cover Architecture, Data Model, API Surface, Frontend, Pipeline, Deployment, and a Development Guide — a comprehensive onboarding surface. The _Sidebar provides grouped navigation. Each page is standalone with inter-page links.
- S02 UAT test cases cover accessibility, page presence, cross-links, and sidebar navigation.


## Verdict Rationale
Both slices delivered their claimed outputs with verification evidence. Contract (artifact existence + completeness), Integration (actionable recommendations), Operational (wiki accessible via API), and UAT (comprehensive onboarding docs) verification classes all pass. The forgejo.xpltd.co → git.xpltd.co domain deviation is documented and cosmetic. Known limitations (creator count mismatch, stale pipeline pages, wiki snapshot freshness) are pre-existing data issues, not M018 delivery gaps.
