---
verdict: needs-attention
remediation_round: 0
---

# Milestone Validation: M005

## Success Criteria Checklist
## Success Criteria (derived from Vision + Slice "After this" claims)

- [x] **Admin page at /admin/pipeline shows video list with status** — S01 summary confirms 3 videos with processing_status, event_count, total_tokens_used. Live API returns correct data (`GET /admin/pipeline/videos` → 200 with 3 items). UAT tests cover this.
- [x] **Retrigger button dispatches tasks** — S01 summary confirms retrigger button wired to `POST /admin/pipeline/trigger/{video_id}`. Endpoint returns 200. UAT TC6 covers this.
- [x] **Log viewer with token counts and expandable JSON responses** — S01 summary confirms event log timeline with stage, event_type, token counts, and collapsible `JsonViewer` component. UAT TC3-TC4 cover this.
- [x] **Technique page 2-column layout at desktop, single column on mobile** — S02 summary confirms CSS grid 1fr+22rem layout with 768px breakpoint collapse. Browser-verified at desktop and 375px mobile. UAT TC1-TC3 cover this.
- [x] **Key moment cards: title on own line, metadata on secondary row** — S03 summary confirms title promoted to standalone h3, metadata moved to `__meta` flex row. Old `__header` class fully removed. UAT TC1-TC2 cover this.
- [~] **Token counts visible in dashboard** — S01 known limitation: `total_tokens_used` shows 0 for all videos because no pipeline runs have occurred since the instrumentation fix. The wiring is correct but the feature is unexercised with real data.

## Slice Delivery Audit
## Slice Delivery Audit

| Slice | Claimed Deliverable | Evidence | Verdict |
|-------|-------------------|----------|---------|
| S01: Pipeline Admin Dashboard | Admin page at /admin/pipeline with video list, retrigger, log viewer with token counts and JSON | Summary: 5 API endpoints, AdminPipeline.tsx page, JsonViewer component, worker status. Live verification: `GET /admin/pipeline/videos` returns 3 videos, `GET /admin/pipeline/worker-status` returns online worker. All 7 containers healthy. | ✅ Delivered |
| S02: Technique Page 2-Column Layout | 2-column at desktop, single column on mobile | Summary: CSS grid 1fr+22rem with sticky sidebar, 768px breakpoint. Page max-width widened to 64rem. tsc + Vite build pass. Browser-verified both layouts. D019 decision recorded. | ✅ Delivered |
| S03: Key Moment Card Redesign | Title on own line, metadata on clean secondary row | Summary: Title extracted to standalone h3, metadata to __meta flex row. Old __header class fully removed. tsc + Vite build pass. Zero dead CSS. | ✅ Delivered |

## Cross-Slice Integration
## Cross-Slice Integration

**S02 → S03 dependency:** S03 explicitly consumed S02's 22rem sidebar width constraint (decision D019). S03's summary confirms: "The key moment cards in the technique page sidebar previously used a single `__header` flex row... At the 22rem sidebar width (established by S02/D019)..." — boundary correctly honored.

**S01 is independent** of S02/S03 — no cross-slice integration points. S01 operates on the /admin/pipeline namespace while S02/S03 modify /technique/* pages. No conflicts.

No boundary mismatches detected.

## Requirement Coverage
## Requirement Coverage

**R006 (Technique Page Display)** — Already validated in M001. Advanced by S02 (2-column layout) and S03 (key moment card redesign). Both improvements enhance the existing validated requirement without invalidating it.

**R015 (30-Second Retrieval Target)** — Active, not addressed by M005. This is a UX performance requirement owned by M001/S05, not in scope for this milestone's vision (admin dashboard + layout refinements).

All other requirements (R001-R014) are already validated from prior milestones and not in scope for M005.

**No unaddressed requirements within M005's scope.** The milestone addressed what it set out to: admin pipeline tooling and technique page presentation improvements.

## Verification Class Compliance
## Verification Classes

### Contract ✅
> All three admin dashboard features work: video list with status, retrigger button dispatches tasks, log viewer shows token counts. Technique page 2-column layout verified at desktop and mobile viewports. Key moment cards have consistent multi-row layout.

- Video list: Live `GET /admin/pipeline/videos` returns 3 videos with status, event_count, total_tokens_used — **PASS**
- Retrigger: `POST /admin/pipeline/trigger/{video_id}` endpoint exists and returns 200 — **PASS** (note: not tested with active pipeline run)
- Log viewer with token counts: `GET /admin/pipeline/events/{video_id}` returns paginated events with token fields and JSONB payloads — **PASS** (token values are 0 due to no post-fix pipeline runs)
- 2-column layout: S02 browser-verified at desktop and 375px mobile — **PASS**
- Key moment cards: S03 confirmed title h3 + __meta row structure, dead CSS removed — **PASS**

### Integration ⚠️
> Pipeline trigger from dashboard dispatches real Celery tasks. Token counts from LLM responses appear in dashboard. Technique page layout renders correctly with real pipeline data.

- Pipeline trigger dispatches Celery tasks: Endpoint wired, worker online, but no end-to-end trigger test was executed with a real pipeline run — **PARTIAL** (S01 known limitation)
- Token counts from LLM responses: Instrumentation wired but `total_tokens_used=0` for all videos — no pipeline runs since fix — **PARTIAL** (S01 known limitation)
- Technique page layout with real data: S02 browser-verified on ub01 with real technique pages — **PASS**

### Operational ✅
> Dashboard deployed on ub01:8096/admin/pipeline, all API endpoints respond. Frontend builds clean with zero TypeScript errors.

- All 7 containers healthy (verified live: `docker ps --filter name=chrysopedia`)
- `GET /admin/pipeline/videos` → 200 (verified live)
- `GET /admin/pipeline/worker-status` → 200 with online=true (verified live)
- Frontend at `/admin/pipeline` returns HTTP 200 (S01 verification)
- tsc --noEmit: zero errors (S02, S03 verification)
- npm run build: succeeds for all slices

### UAT ✅
> Visual verification of dashboard with pipeline data, technique page at multiple viewports, key moment card layout consistency.

- S01 UAT: 8 test cases covering video list, event log, JSON viewer, worker status, retrigger/revoke, API direct verification
- S02 UAT: 6 test cases + 2 edge cases covering desktop 2-column, sticky sidebar, mobile collapse, page width, visual regressions, empty sections
- S03 UAT: 7 test cases covering title line, metadata row, summary placement, missing filename, semantic HTML, mobile layout, badge consistency


## Verdict Rationale
Verdict: needs-attention. All three slices delivered their claimed outputs. All operational checks pass — the stack is deployed and healthy, all API endpoints respond, frontend builds clean. The two minor gaps are both in S01's integration tier: (1) token counts show 0 because no pipeline has run since the instrumentation fix, and (2) retrigger/revoke haven't been tested with an active pipeline run. Both are expected consequences of the instrumentation being fixed mid-milestone without a subsequent pipeline execution — the wiring is demonstrably correct (events table has 24+ events, endpoints return structured data), just unexercised with post-fix data. These do not warrant remediation slices — the next natural pipeline run will validate both. Documenting as attention items rather than blocking completion.
